BEST BURGERS.co·San Francisco
Cole Valley Tavern — Tavern SmashBurger

#9 in San Francisco

Cole Valley Tavern

Tavern SmashBurger

3.92/ 5Final Score
Dimension Averages
Meat
4.08
Bun
3.67
Essence
4.00
Individual Ratings
Jason
4.08
their #10 of 66
+0.17 vs crew
3.754.004.50
Stu
4.50
their #2 of 65
+0.58 vs crew
4.505.004.00
Anthony
3.17
their #36 of 66
−0.75 vs crew
4.002.003.50
Bang for Buck
$0.19/ptRank #51

The Burger Guys' Review

Reviewed January 8, 2024

The Tavern SmashBurger at Cole Valley Tavern is a delightful conundrum of flavors and textures. The bun, with its firm exterior and smooth bite, is a standout, though opinions vary on its greasiness and dominance. The patty, while slightly under-seasoned and occasionally dry, offers a crispy texture that pairs well with the sauces, particularly the thousand island dressing, which some find a tad overpowering. Despite these quirks, the burger's overall essence is commendable, with a harmonious balance that invites a repeat visit. A solid choice for those seeking a unique burger experience, even if the lettuce might be an unnecessary guest at this flavor party.

Price$21
NeighborhoodCole Valley
Address906 Cole St, San Francisco, CA 94117

Share:

Twitter / X